Hire an expert+Submit a test
Tests
Ecommerce
All ecommerce tests1219Winning testsTests that lostTest ideas698Every vertical1724
By page
Product page492Cart96Checkout58Collection page143Homepage133Landing page67Navigation & menu60Post-purchase3
SaaS
All SaaS tests205Landing page51Homepage30Pricing page26Signup page18Checkout13
Lead-gen
All Lead-gen tests220Landing page94Lead form43Homepage23Email18Site-wide17
Apps
All app tests80Paywall71App onboarding7App retention2App CRO overviewARPU calculatorApp icon generator
Featured win
A
→
B
+$182k monthly revenueAdded bundle options directly on the product page
Ecommerce, SaaS, lead-gen and app tests in one database. Share a test →
Elements
Trust and proof
Reviews & star ratings87Social proof, authority & press81UGC & product video29Money-back guarantee & returns51Trust badges & security seals56Bestseller badges & product labels44
Offers and pricing
Pricing, discounts & savings display119Bundles & quantity breaks49Upsells & cross-sells86Subscriptions & subscribe-and-save52Free shipping thresholds & shipping price38Countdown timers22
Layout and content
Product images & gallery100Hero & above-the-fold section75Headlines, product titles & copy129Sticky add-to-cart bars36Navigation & mega menus128Shipping & delivery messaging83
All 44 elements → · Browse by page type →
Guides
Learn
CRO guideA/B testing guideThe CRO processStatistical significanceA/B testing mistakes
Benchmarks
A/B testing statisticsEcommerce conversion rateConversion rate by industryShopify conversion rateCart abandonment rate
Calculators and checklists
Significance calculatorSample size calculatorConversion rate calculatorEcommerce CRO checklistProduct page checklist
Tools
Best tools
A/B testing toolsShopify A/B testing appsHeatmap toolsPage buildersReview apps
Reviews and comparisons
Intelligems vs ShopliftVWO vs ConvertConvert reviewIntelligems reviewPageFly vs GemPages
Free LiftArchive tools
LiftVerdict™ significanceLiftTimer™ sample sizeLiftARPU™ ARPU calculatorLiftIcon™ app iconsUse LiftArchive with AI
Statistics
SaaS testsLead-gen testsApp testsHire an expertSubmit a test

Ribbons, reviews and quick add on listings: +22.16% add-to-cart

WinnerSeveral changes tested togetherCollection page
C
Test run byConvertPoloCRO agency
Commentary byLiftArchiveOur analysis, not theirs

Adding product ribbons, reviews, collection banners and quick-action buttons to mobile listing pages lifted add-to-cart rate by 22.16% for My Sanskritam.

The agency ConvertPolo ran the test, and it was published as a VWO case study.

Several changes shipped together, so no single one gets the credit.

+22.16% add-to-cart
  • Add-to-cart rate: +22.16%.
  • Revenue conversion: +4.51%, a much smaller gain than the add-to-cart lift.
  • This was a bundled change, so the effect of each element is unknown.

The change

Control (A)
header
filters
Image, name, price
product card
footer
Variant (B)
header
Collection bannerNEW
filters
New In / Best Seller ribbonNEW
Image, name, price
Customer reviewsNEW
Add to Cart, Quick ViewNEW
footer

Listing cards gain ribbons, reviews and quick actions together

Simplified mockup drawn by LiftArchive from the shared screenshots.

Control

The mobile product listing page had no tags, no reviews and no quick actions on the product cards.

Variant

Cards gained "New In" and "Best Seller" ribbons and customer reviews. The page also added collection banners and prominent "Add to Cart" and "Quick View" buttons.

Why it likely won

Our reading of the result, not the practitioner's claim.

  • Quick add lets shoppers add items without opening the product page, which makes add-to-cart easier but doesn't always lead to purchase.
  • Ribbons help shoppers spot popular and new items fast.
  • Reviews on the cards add social proof before a click.

Caveats: Ribbons, reviews, banners and buttons all launched together, so the result can't be pinned on one element. No sample size, duration or significance was shared.

Who ran it

ConvertPolo ran this test for My Sanskritam and published the results (VWO case study). The numbers are theirs; the summary and commentary on this page are ours.

Read the original case study on ConvertPolo →

How to run this test on your store

Hypothesis
If we add popularity ribbons, reviews and quick add buttons to listing cards, then more shoppers will add items and buy, because they can judge and act on products without extra taps.
Primary metric
Revenue per visitor
Guardrails
  • Add-to-cart rate
  • Cart abandonment rate
  • Product page views
Who should test it
Mobile stores with simple products, such as apparel with few options. Quick add helps less where shoppers must pick sizes or customize, and it may raise add-to-cart more than sales.

Questions

Does quick add on collection pages help?

It can raise add-to-cart. Here a bundle including quick add lifted add-to-cart 22.16%, but revenue conversion rose only 4.51%.

Should product cards show reviews?

Star ratings on cards add social proof early.

Test them on their own to know their real effect.

Why did add-to-cart rise more than revenue?

Quick add makes adding easy, so some shoppers add items they don't buy.

Judge these tests on revenue, not add-to-cart alone.

Similar tests

A
→
B
+$135,307/month
Added Quick Add buttons to collection page product cards
Collection pageProduct cards & quick add@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
+$118,000 per month
Added best-seller labels and tightened collection page fold so products show earlier
Collection pageBestseller badges & product labels@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
$56,285/month
Mobile collection cards in 2x2 grid with quick add-to-cart button
Collection pageProduct cards & quick add@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
+$49,040/month
Collection page: switched to 2x2 grid and reordered top performers
Collection pageSubscriptions & subscribe-and-save@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
$44,890/month
Three survey-based reassurance lines above collection page grid
Collection pageUSP bars & benefit icons@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
$43,115/month
Realigned collection page product cards, highlighted flavour names
Collection pageProduct cards & quick add@oliverkenyon