Landing Page Layout & Redesign Tests: 3 Results, 10 Ideas

All 3 measured landing page layout tests won, and the most useful pattern is that rebuilding the page, either faster or with a clearer opening, beat tweaking it.

Oliver Kenyon rebuilt the same landing page natively in Shopify instead of a page builder for +9.9% conversion rate and +20.9% revenue per visitor.

Josh Thompson's new page design reported +137.26% conversion rate.

Three results is thin evidence, and none were losses, so use these as test ideas rather than rules.

7measured results
7–0won vs lost or flat
9ideas to test
$96,211biggest est. monthly gain
A
→
B
Mobile conversion 2% to 4.5%
Mobile-first entry landing pages with simple form and trust proof for a prize draw brand
Landing pageLayout, fonts & visual design@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
+40% funnel conversion rate
Funnel and product page redesign with 3-step buy flow for a brain drink brand
Landing pageLayout, fonts & visual design@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
Conversion rate 1.6% to 9.52%
Landing page overhaul with ordering steps and client proof for a print brand
Landing pageBenefit, problem, how-it-works & results sections@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
+20.9% revenue per visitor
Rebuilt landing page natively in Shopify vs same page in a page builder
Landing pageLayout, fonts & visual design@oliverkenyon
A
→
B
+12.20% revenue per visitor
Redesigned the advertorial hero, rewrote the opening copy and added product images above the fold
Landing pageHero & above-the-fold section@DaveDiederen
A
→
B
+175.64% revenue per visitor
New page design tested against the existing page in Intelligems
Landing pageLayout, fonts & visual design@joshtCRO
A
→
B
Boosted conversion for some brands (no figures)
Increase body font size by 2px
Landing pageAdvertorials, listicles & presell pages@kasper_dolk
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
Hero redesign: outcome headline, benefits, guarantee and press logos (Vivoflex)
Landing pageReviews & star ratings@CROguy_
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
Above-the-fold layout: proof, tagline, outcome headline, CTA, guarantee
Landing pageSocial proof, authority & press@CROguy_
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
Landing page section order: headline, social proof, problem, benefits, offer, comparison
Landing pageReviews & star ratings@kasper_dolk
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
Rebuilt the landing page with ad-matched messaging, product + benefit + offer above the fold and an on-page order form
Landing pageHero & above-the-fold section@joshtCRO
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
JBL promo landing page redesign
Landing pageReviews & star ratings@Rubendgrf
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
Use listicle landing pages for cold traffic
Landing pageAdvertorials, listicles & presell pages@kasper_dolk
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
Listicle pages for TOF/MOF traffic
Landing pageSocial proof, authority & press@kasper_dolk
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
Rebuilt a landing page: copy matched to the top ad, benefit headline and social proof above the fold, order form on the page
Landing pageSocial proof, authority & press@joshtCRO
A
→
B
Idea, no result yet
Hero redesign: problem-solving headline for a cat feeder (PurrHeaven)
Landing pageTrust badges & security seals@CROguy_

Why layout matters on landing pages

Landing pages carry paid traffic, so load speed and the first screen decide whether the click was worth paying for.

The three results cover both: one is a technical rebuild, two are design changes.

Measured results

Same page, built differently

Oliver Kenyon rebuilt a landing page natively in Shopify and tested it against the same page in a page builder: +9.9% CVR, +20.9% RPV and +10.0% AOV.

The design stayed the same, which makes this one of the cleaner tests in the archive.

Redesigned openings

Dave Diederen redesigned an advertorial hero, rewrote the opening copy and added product images above the fold: +12.26% CVR, +12.20% RPV and +11.54% profit per visitor, reported as $1M in additional yearly revenue, with AOV unchanged.

Josh Thompson tested a new page design against the existing page in Intelligems: +137.26% CVR, +175.64% RPV, +181.51% profit per visitor and +16.18% AOV, estimated at +$51,423/month.

A lift this large usually means the old page had big problems, so expect less on a page that already works.

Losing or flat tests

No losses were shared. Kasper Dolk also reports that raising body font size by 2px boosted conversion for some brands with older audiences, but gave no figures.

Untested ideas

  • Kasper Dolk suggests a section order of emotional headline, review banner, problem deep-dive, benefits, product block, store benefits, reviews and an us-vs-them comparison.
  • Kasper also suggests listicle landing pages for cold and warm traffic, since they make it easy to test new hooks.
  • Milos's teardowns lead with rating and customer count, an outcome headline, a CTA with a guarantee and press logos.
  • Ruben's JBL promo redesign swaps a generic free-shipping bar for a time-bound offer and a slogan for a benefit headline.
  • Josh Thompson describes ad-matched rebuilds with an on-page order form, with claimed gains but no test data shown.

Placement and design patterns that won

  • Native Shopify sections over a page builder.
  • Product images and a rewritten opening above the fold.
  • Full redesigns tested against the existing page, not just small edits.

Related tests elsewhere on the store

See landing page benefit section tests, landing page headline tests, theme and page speed tests and advertorial and listicle tests.

Questions

Are page builders bad for landing page conversion?

In one test, the native version won. Oliver Kenyon rebuilt the same landing page natively in Shopify and gained +9.9% conversion rate and +20.9% revenue per visitor over the page builder version.

What landing page redesign had the biggest result?

Josh Thompson's new page design tested in Intelligems reported +137.26% conversion rate and +175.64% revenue per visitor, estimated at +$51,423/month.

Does font size matter on landing pages?

Kasper Dolk reports that a 2px increase in body font size boosted conversion for some brands with older audiences, but shared no figures, so it is an idea worth testing rather than a measured result.